Raw cookie dough’s flour could make you really sick
Scientists linked one recent food-poisoning outbreak to bacteria in flour
Eggs have long been condemned for making raw cookie dough a dangerous, forbidden pleasure. But they can stop taking all the blame. Here’s a new reason to resist the sweet uncooked temptation: flour.
The seemingly innocuous pantry staple can harbor strains of E. coli bacteria that make people sick. Flour is not a particularly common source of foodborne illness. But it has been implicated in two E. coli outbreaks in the United States and Canada in the last two years.
The U.S. outbreak sickened 63 people between December 2015 and September 2016. Pinning down tainted flour as the source was trickier than the average food-poisoning investigation. Researchers described their hunt, last month, in the New England Journal of Medicine.
Usually, state health departments rely on standard questionnaires to find a common culprit for a cluster of reported illnesses, says Samuel Crowe. And, he notes, flour isn’t usually tracked on these surveys. Crowe is an epidemiologist (Ep-ih-dee-me-OLL-uh-gizt) — health detective — at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in Atlanta, Ga. He also led the study.
The initial investigation yielded uncertain results. That’s when public health researchers turned to in-depth personal interviews with 10 people who had fallen ill.
Crowe spent up to two hours asking each person detailed questions about what he or she had eaten around the time of getting sick. Asking people what they ate eight weeks ago can be challenging, Crowe says. Many people can’t even remember what they ate for breakfast that morning.
“I got a little lucky,” Crowe says. Two people remembered eating raw cookie dough before getting sick. They each sent Crowe pictures of the bag of flour they had used to make the batter. It turned out that both bags had been produced in the same plant. That was a “pretty unusual thing,” he adds.
Follow-up questioning helped Crowe and his team pin down flour as the likely source. Eventually, scientists at the U.S. Food and Drug Administration analyzed the flour. They isolated strains of E. coli bacteria that produce Shiga (SHE-guh) toxin. This poison makes people ill. It’s what can make E. coli deadly.
Disease-causing bacteria, including E. coli, usually thrive in moist environments, like bags of prewashed lettuce. But the bacteria can also survive in a dried-out state for months and be re-activated with water, says Crowe. So as soon as dry flour mingles with eggs or oil, dormant bacteria can reawaken and start to replicate.
Cookie dough wasn’t the culprit in every case. A few children who got sick had been given raw tortilla dough to play with while waiting for a table at a restaurant. But the cases all involved wheat flour from the same facility. That led to a recall of more than 250 flour-containing products.
There are ways to kill bacteria in flour before it reaches grocery store shelves. However, they aren’t in use in the United States. Heat treatment, for example, will rid flour of E. coli and other pathogens. But the process also changes the structure of the flour. This affects the texture of baked goods, says Rick Holley. He’s a food safety expert at the University of Manitoba in Canada who wasn’t part of the study. Irradiation, used to kill parasites and other pests in flour, might be a better option, Holley says. But it takes a higher dose of radiation to zap bacteria than it does to kill pests.
Or, of course, people could hold out for warm, freshly baked cookies.